Community stories
educationby Mrs Wells · 631 words · 611 views

The Viva

Eight years part-time. Two supervisors, one of whom retired halfway. A thesis on canal drainage in the 1790s that nobody in your family has read. Today you defend it.

You are fifty-two years old and you are sitting outside a seminar room in a building you've visited maybe twenty times in eight years, because you did all of this from the kitchen table in Wakefield, on weeknights, after the day job, after the kids, after the dishwasher was on. The chair is plastic. Someone has left a coffee cup on the windowsill. Inside, two examiners are reading your thesis. Or pretending to. They've read it already, obviously, they've had it for two months. They've made notes. One of them, the external, is a man whose books you cited forty-one times, and you know this because you counted at 3am last Tuesday in a fit of something. Eight years. You've told the story so often it's gone flat. You did an evening MA when the youngest started secondary and you'd been in the archives in Leeds one Saturday and found a bundle of letters between an engineer and a landowner about a culvert, and something in the handwriting made you want to know what happened to the culvert. That's it. That's the whole reason. It became a chapter and then it became a proposal and then it became your life for a decade in a way nobody in your house fully understood, though they were kind about it. Your husband learned to say "the culvert" the way other husbands say "the golf." Your supervisor retired in year five. The new one was good but younger than you, and there was a period of a few months where you didn't know how to talk to her, or she to you, and you both pretended it wasn't strange. The door opens. "We're ready for you." The room is smaller than you thought it would be. They're both smiling, which means nothing. Your supervisor sits at the side, not allowed to speak. There's a jug of water. "Let's start easy," the internal says. "Tell us how you came to this topic." You tell them about the culvert. You've told it a hundred times, and this time, for some reason, it comes out differently. You hear yourself say "I just wanted to know what happened," and something in the external's face changes, softens, and you think, oh. That's the same reason he does it. That's why anyone does it.
The next two hours are hard. They should be. He pushes you on your methodology in chapter four and he's right and you say so, and then you say why you did it anyway, and he nods. The internal asks about a source you'd dismissed in a footnote and you find, to your surprise, that you can explain exactly why, with dates. There's a moment where you disagree with the external about the significance of a particular Act, and you hold your ground, and you feel your supervisor go still at the side of the room, and then the external says, "Fair. I hadn't thought about it like that," and writes something down. Then they send you out. The plastic chair. The coffee cup. Eleven minutes, which you count on the clock above the stairwell. The door opens and your supervisor is the one standing there, and she's grinning, and she says, "Doctor," and that's how you find out. Minor corrections. Six weeks. You'll do them from the kitchen table. On the train home you don't tell anyone. You want to hold it for a bit, this one thing, the way you held the letters in the archive that first Saturday, before it belonged to anyone else. Somewhere near Leeds your phone buzzes. It's your husband. "Well??" "Well," you type. "The culvert got its doctorate." Then you look out the window at the fields, which are full of drains nobody notices, and you notice every one.

How hot is it?

Not rated yet
#phd#part-time#mature-student#uk#second-person

Themes: phd viva · part time student · uk education · thesis defense · academic achievement · research · methodology · supervision · phd journey

Comments

Loading comments…